You make assumptions and draw conclusions about me because you have
not asked me directly. I have also made assumptions about you. This is natural
when two people have not had contact or communicated freely and met together as
adults and friends to discuss and come to understandings and meeting of the
minds. I would like to have contact with you because I wish to stop making
assumptions about you, because I think this is harmful. I would genuinely like
to understand who you are. This will help me with my decisions.
Consider the assumptions I could make about you (and, at various
times, have made about you):
1)
You are, and always have
been the man I knew and love. You are the man I continue to love. You are
compelled to say and do things you do not believe in order to protect yourself
and protect me. When we interact, you cannot say what you think or
feel, and you feel sad that your actions and words are so hurtful, and you have
compassion for the pain you cause. If this is true, then I am obliged (indeed, I
would very much wish) to aid and protect you.
2)
You were the man I knew and
love. You are also a coward. You lacked the character to stand up to social
pressure and you preferred comfort over truth. Your previous decisions are
uncomfortable because they were made in a time when you were morally brave, and
you sense your own weakness now. You are ashamed of yourself. Your cruel
behavior towards me is a reflection of this discomfort. If this is
true, then such a man does not deserve protection. Indeed, he deserves to
receive the things he fears most. I would not desire to be with this man, and I
would ensure that he paid for his cowardice and cruelty. To the anger and fear
you have expressed to me, I say: I have never harassed your work or private
life. You would certainly know if I had.
3)
You are not the man I knew
and love. You destroyed that man. If you are the person responsible for the
destruction of someone I loved so dearly, then I would very much wish to harm
you. When we spoke in December, I had come to believe this about you, and this
is what I felt when I told you that I "didn't want anything" from you. I was
prepared (on the following day) to travel to the courthouse and put your name on
the criminal complaint alongside Mac. You felt that our conversation did not
benefit you at all. You were mistaken. After our conversation, I had doubts, so
I did not act against you.
At first, I believed that one of these assumptions was the “truth”.
I believed that, if I had an unambigious answer to a simple question on
facebook, I would know which scenario was correct. But I have come to realize
that these were only assumptions and that some fourth possibility may exist that
I have not considered. This thought has haunted me for the past few weeks and is
the reason I've sought additional contact. I have so little real knowledge of
the man you are now. I would like to know and understand that man. I would like
to stop making assumptions.
You ask me what I want. Not to put too fine a point on it: I want a
reason not to seek retribution. I ask you, “does the man I knew still exist?”
because this answer will bring me peace, one way or the other.
You accuse me of harming you, or desiring to harm you. I have not. Before
you draw conclusions about my motivations, consider the variety of ways in which
I could have acted. If you make assumptions about me, then consider what I might
have done and allow my restraint to factor into your image of me. Perhaps you
still see me as the broken person you created. I am not broken. I am not happy
(as you say you are) but I am extremely strong and driven and capable.
My continued feeling of love and loyalty for the man I knew is
not a weakness: it has stayed my hand when I might have unleashed hell.
I understand your reluctance to have a genuine interaction with me. I
don’t blame you for this. Continued interaction with me is not good for you in
any of the scenarios I outline above. But this exchange is to determine
whether another, alternate, scenario exists. I doubt that this message
will make you feel comfortable and eager to engage. But I do feel that it’s
right to let you know where I stand and what I want, because I would like a real
exchange. No more assumptions.
Would you be willing to enter into a dialogue with me? I can’t
guarantee the timeframe for the exchange, nor the outcome. But I come to the
table with an open mind and heart. I am willing to learn about you and to know
more about you. Would you like to set aside your own assumptions and learn more
and know more about me?
